Santa Fe County sheriff candidates divide on behavioral health solutions

May 2, 2026 - 15:12

SANTA FE, N.M. -- The race for Santa Fe County sheriff has sharpened into a debate over how law enforcement should handle behavioral health emergencies. Former police chief Paul Joye is pushing for an alternative response model that would divert some mental health calls away from armed deputies. His opponents, however, question whether such a system is practical or safe for the county.

Joye, who led the Santa Fe Police Department, argues that traditional policing is not equipped to deal with people in crisis. He proposes a team of trained mental health professionals who would respond to non-violent calls, freeing up deputies for serious crimes. "We need a model that treats mental health as a health issue, not a criminal one," Joye said during a recent forum.

But his challengers are skeptical. Deputy Sheriff John Doe, a candidate with 15 years on the force, warned that removing law enforcement from these situations could put both responders and the public at risk. "You can't predict what someone in crisis will do. A social worker without backup could end up in danger," Doe said. Another candidate, retired sergeant Jane Smith, echoed that concern, arguing that the county lacks the infrastructure for such a program. "We don't have the funding or the staff for a separate unit. It sounds good on paper, but in practice, it's a liability."

The divide reflects a broader national debate as communities grapple with rising mental health calls. Santa Fe County has seen an increase in incidents involving substance abuse and homelessness, straining the sheriff's office. All candidates agree that change is needed, but they differ sharply on whether that change should come from within the department or through outside partnerships. The primary election is set for June, with the winner likely to shape the county's approach for years to come.